Shopping for the best mattress online is a waking nightmare, and picking the wrong one can literally cause bad dreams or kill your back. It doesn’t help that the online market is flooded with options, or that there are more dedicated mattress review sites than stars in the sky. It’s a mess.
Mattress shopping today is much more complicated. Not only are there more designs and styles, but you can shop at online stores that will deliver a new bed right to your door, sight unseen. How do you choose from such a wide variety of models and companies, and which mattresses are the best available right now?
How Should I Choose A Mattress Topper?
There is a wide variety of mattress toppers on the market and although at the end it boils down to your personal comfort preferences, there are several factors to keep in mind to narrow the choice. Balancing every consideration isn’t necessary, but understanding what to look for can help you shop smarter.
Here are the main points that you will need to keep in perspective:
- Price – No matter how highly rated a mattress is, buyers on a budget will be limited in their range of choices. It’s best to determine your price range before shopping, limiting your selections to the models that are affordable.
- Warranty – Most people keep their mattresses for a long time, so purchase a mattress with at least a ten-year warranty to cover defects.
- Return Policy – It’s difficult to know how a mattress will perform after a quick check in the showroom. If you get your mattress home and find that it doesn’t meet your needs, you will want the assurance that you can return or exchange it easily.
- Store Models – Many people don’t realize that different retailers have their own versions of top-selling models. If you find a mattress that you love at one store, don’t assume that the specs are identical at a competitor’s location.
Today’s Best Creative Solution make a variety of mattress types, and there is a broad range of quality among each product category.
We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, Best Creative Solution may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them.
Do mattress toppers really work?
Overall, mattress toppers have been effective in enhancing the comfort level of new and old mattresses alike, providing a better sleep experience for most people. Memory foam toppers are generally more preferred due to the fact that they are both easily available and provide a significant level of comfort
1. The Best Mattress Pads overfilled microplush topper that’ll be hypoallergenic *and* double as a mattress pad, so your comfy bases are covered.
Fits mattresses up to 18″ deep and filled with loft-retaining, polyester filling.
Promising review: “I thought about ordering a size up to make sure the topper reached the edges of the bed, but I was pleasantly surprised to discover the topper fit perfectly. You can tell it is very well-made and adds just the right touch for the memory foam bed I blindly purchased, which was too hard. My back no longer hurts and I feel rested when I wake up now. This microplush topper turned my overly hard rock of a mattress into a dream bed in comparison to what it was. Truth be told, I may order a second to layer it to make it even fluffier because the pockets of the sheet itself are so deep. I’ll be able to layer it without worrying one side will pop off or something. Very pleased. My puppy loves it too!” —SG
2. The Best Mattress 3-inch dense memory foam pad for a conforming hug meant to relieve pressure points.
Promising review: “I bought this for my wife. She’s pregnant and her hips had been aching sleeping on our mattress. Guess what? She says the pain is gone since we’ve been sleeping on this topper. The topper arrived quickly. I unpacked it and laid it on our floor so it could expand and air out. It didn’t take long at all for it to expand. We put it on our bed the same evening it arrived at our house. I personally didn’t find the smell to be too strong or offensive. I noticed it for 2–3 days, but that’s about it. I’ve been sleeping better since getting the topper. It’s prevented my shoulders from falling asleep when I sleep on my sides. I weigh about 200 lbs, my wife weighs about 150 lbs. (five months pregnant). I’m glad I didn’t buy the 2-inch topper because I don’t think that would have been thick enough.” —Ryan M. Healy
3. Best Mattress Pads gel-infused memory foam number to help you find the perfect position for sleeping — even if you’re nine months pregnant.
Made of a ventilated design infused with gel and comes with a 3-year warranty.
Promising review: “So we’ve now had this for roughly a few months now and it’s the best sleep I’ve gotten in a long time. I’m currently in my ninth month of pregnancy so finding a comfortable sleeping position without a pillow is nearly impossible, but I’m able to sleep a bit better with this on our bed. The only downside is it tears fairly easily, so if you have dogs like us (or even cats) I would be extra careful with having them on the bed due to nails. I highly recommend purchasing!” —Michaela
4. The Best ~cooling~ bamboo topper with a fitted skirt to keep everything in place and counteract any tendencies to sleep hot.
Made of hypoallergenic down alternative RevoLoft Cluster Fiber and fits mattresses up to 18″ deep.
Promising review: “We went from a traditional mattress to a Tempurpedic memory foam mattress (with a cooling gel layer) and we NEVER would have bought it if we realized it retains your body heat and holds it against you. It was too hot even in the winter and I’m always cold. I trusted the reviews of the this bamboo mattress topper and am SO happy I did. It made such a huge difference… I’ve been using it for over a month now and I haven’t sweated once!!! We bought a split king so our mattress covers are twin XL.” —Michelle
5. The Best Mattress Pads ventilated memory foam layer in three thicknesses for finding the perfect fit for your bed.
Made with open-cell technology to prevent lasting body impressions and comes with a 3-year warranty.
Promising review: “Our mattress was a good mattress, at least for me. My husband however has not been able to sleep in our bed without waking up in pain. He travels a lot and when he stays at a hotel, his back is fine. We were looking into replacing the entire mattress but decided to try this first. So glad we did. He has been able to sleep on this and wake up pain-free. It didn’t take long for it to completely fill out, and there is an odor like new carpet or vinyl, but it’s faint. I’m sensitive to smells, but with our mattress cover and sheets covering it, I don’t notice it. Update: We’ve owned this mattress topper for almost a year now and since we’ve owned it my husband has not complained of back pain. It has not compressed or changed shape. The odor is completely gone and did not take long to disappear. We are incredibly happy with the purchase.” —B. Richardson
6. Best Mattress Pads That’ll Fit Easily Underneath Your Fitted Sheet Visco elastic foam topper because it’s an inch shorter on the sides.
Made of a polymer design to keep cool air in and hot air out.
Promising review: “I purchased this topper for my 26-year-old daughter’s queen size bed. Since getting her new mattress, she would often wake up with an aching or stiff back. She is on her feet for 8–10 hours a day at her job. We went on Amazon and found this one. The topper is very thick and like the description said, it does not stay flattened down when she gets out of bed. It was very easy to put on her bed and just as easy to make the bed. She told me that she was ‘ready for a struggle with it!’ But the edges are tapered and a little thinner so it was very easy to put the fitted sheet on. And one of the biggest pluses is that it does not retain heat or make her hot at night. We were concerned about that because she lives in Florida. She loves it and it has really helped her back. This topper is well worth the price, which was a steal in my opinion.” —pms531
7. Mattress Pads cushy topper duo because you can and should have it all when it comes to your bedding sitch.
Includes 2 inches of quilted fiber fill with 2 inches of memory foam, and comes with a 10-year limited warranty.
Promising review: “After undergoing my eighth back surgery in the last nine years, just recently, I purchased this to place on top of my Sleep Number bed. I am thin and HAVE to sleep on my right side in a fetal position every night of my life since being a passenger in an auto accident in 1999. I developed ‘pressure point sores’ (a.k.a. bed sores) on my hip, I am only 47 years old and do NOT lay in bed other than to sleep! THIS PRODUCT HAS CHANGED MY LIFE!!!! I wake up NOT HURTING, and with great care, my pressure point sores are 100% healed! It is no longer uncomfortable to lay down on my side, this 4″ of gentle softness now allows me to actually SLEEP WELL!!! I cannot recommend this to those with arthritis and back pain HIGHLY ENOUGH! I spent HOURS AND HOURS reading every review, comparing, and researching. I wish I had found this MANY YEARS AGO!!!!” —MimiX5boys
8. Best Overall Mattress 2-inch memory foam topper to make a too-firm mattress so much easier to sleep on through the night.
Comes with a 5-year warranty.
Promising review: “This was a LIFE SAVER. My husband and I bought a mattress on clearance. It was extra firm and on clearance for a reason (we learned after one night of sleeping on it). It was like a brick. We both have back problems and knew we wanted firm, but this made my limbs go numb if I slept on my side. It is still firm but seriously turned my bed into something perfect. I will never hesitate to buy a cheap clearance mattress again because I know there is a quick fix and this is it.” —Claire S.
9. Best Mattress gel-memory foam swirl topper available in three thicknesses as a breathable option that’ll cradle your sore spots.
Made of open-cell memory foam with gel infusions.
Promising review: “We put this on top of our (very uncomfortable) camper mattress (short queen size). It was easy to trim to length with a utility knife. The mattress fluffed up to full size in less than 24 hours, but definitely had a unique smell to it during this time. We simply opened a few windows to the camper the first full day with it, and the smell went away. The RV mattress is now so comfortable. The topper did not make me hot at all. I slept great each night and didn’t wake up sore at any point in time! Normally after a few nights on the RV mattress, I dread sleeping. No so anymore! It was definitely worth it!” —Shaun S.
10. A foam topper with a removable cover you can wash, in case you’re one of those people who washes your bedding as often as you should. (And good for you!)
Made of 2-inch gel memory foam and a machine-washable bamboo cover.
Promising review: “One of the best purchases I’ve made in my life. It’s so comfy I often giggle when I get into bed. I’ve had memory foam pads before, this is SO much better. The thick smooth cover helps immensely, my sheets can move with me instead of getting stuck on the pad. The cover has stay-put dots on the underside so it won’t roam around the bed. The bed hasn’t felt hot, even when it was over 80 degrees in the house, I think that’s where the gel part comes in. I personally like the 2-inch best. Much thicker and I kinda get stuck in the bed and my feet and hands are too high compared to the rest of me. 1-inch pads don’t do much comforting for me. This is the Goldilocks of mattress pads. Just right.” —debs
11. A 2-inch down alternative mattress pad to give you the feel of a featherbed for significantly less dough.
Made of a premium microfiber shell with down alternative polyfill.
Promising review: “This is the BEST mattress pad I have ever bought. PERIOD. I have paid up to $180 for mattress toppers that aren’t this good. One reviewer commented about the fact that it didn’t have the stretchy fabric that hold the mattress pad onto the mattress. You don’t need it with this, and you don’t want it with this. When you change sheets, just shake this and fluff it, turn it over if you want, and you’re good to go. The other type pads that have the elastic polyester sides only compress the pads, trust me, I have half a dozen. This does not sleep hot at all. The loft is close to 3 inches. And there is no feather fill sticking to you either like from a feather bed topper. I’ve been waking up for quite a long time with my hips killing me, turning side to side all night long. Not anymore. If you want a good mattress topper, you really should try this one. It is very comfortable. Sleeping is a pleasure again.” —MRH
12. Best Mattress Pad for order odor-eliminating option — you won’t have to worry about it smelling funny because your dog *has* to sleep with you.
Made of cool gel memory foam with green tea extract and castor natural seed oil for odor elimination, and comes with a 5-year warranty.
Promising review: “Was actually quite surprised by the comfort this brought. I do not sleep well at all and do not sleep solidly, or reach REM usually. Since getting it I’ve slept on it three times and each time I quickly fall asleep, I am extremely comfortable, and I sleep very deeply. I have had a 2-inch memory foam pad and it didn’t offer the support this does because it didn’t have the high-density crap. Seriously happy and seriously recommend it if you don’t sleep well at night” —Patrick H.[the_ad id=”674″]
13. A charcoal bamboo foam topper to help regulate moisture, temperature, and odor.
Hypoallergenic, and infused with bamboo and charcoal.
Promising review: “Great Scott! When I get fired for not coming into work, can I sue this company? I ask because man, I do NOT want to get out of bed in the morning. I purchased the queen size, and I am not joking about this; I have slept better since putting this on my bed (and no, I did not wait the suggested 48 hours) than I have in years! I have sleep apnea, and if I lay on my right side, my hip starts to hurt, and if I lay on my left side, my sinuses clog up on that side making breathing difficult. With this mattress topper, I am able to actually lay on my back and fall asleep for the first time in years!” —Danny
14. A natural latex topper for soft but supportive firmness, without synthetic fillers.
Made of 100% natural latex foam.
Promising review: “Can’t recommend this enough. I have this 3” latex soft topper on both of my beds now — bedroom and daybed. I need a firm support mattress, but my joints hate it. With the soft toppers, I get to keep my firm mattress support, but the topper makes it feel like I’m sleeping on a cloud. It’s so comfortable I look forward to bedtime or siesta. I put a nice TV in the bedroom a few years ago, but I haven’t been able to watch a single thing because I fall asleep within a minute or two of climbing into bed. If you have problems getting comfortable on a firm bed, don’t make the mistake of buying a soft mattress that will offer poor support. Just get a soft topper! Your body will thank you. I use a deep mattress cover and BedVoyage bamboo sheets (deep corners), which only add to the comfort level.” —M. Spalding
15. Best Mattress Pad thicc down-alternative topper with stretchy bands to keep the pillowy surface in place.
Measures 2-inch thick and made of hypoallergenic down-alternative fiber filling.
Promising review: “AWESOME, AWESOME, AWESOME!!! Believe this or not, I spent the money on a memory foam mattress that the salesman said was ‘tailored’ to someone with my back and neck problems. The memory foam was the most uncomfortable surface I have ever lain on, and if you spend too much time on one side, that side’s shoulder starts to hurt. I bought this pillow-top mattress cover, and wish I had gotten it in ’06 when I bought the mattress, and instead of the mattress. If you want a mattress top that cushions where you need cushioning, and lets you snuggle down into it when you sleep. this is IT!” —Matthew M[the_ad id=”675″]
16. Best Mattress pad For Relaxing~ lavender-infused topper ventilated design that’ll lull you to sleep.
Made of ventilated memory foam infused with lavender scent.
Promising review: “After many glorious nights of sleep I consider this mattress topper to be an investment. I don’t know how I’ve lived without it. It perfectly conforms to my shape without making me feel like I’m sinking. I can actually sleep comfortably on my back. And, when I get out of bed, the topper returns back to its original shape just like memory foam is supposed to. Also, the fragrance is heavenly. It was a little strong the first night, but not so strong that I couldn’t sleep. I ignored the package instructions that said to unroll the pad and let it lie in a flat place for about 48 hours prior to use so that it could reshape itself and so that the fragrance could die down a little. But, once I received the topper I didn’t want to wait two more days to use it! For those of you out there who are considering buying this mattress topper, please be aware it’s going to look oddly lumpy when you first unroll it. Be patient and don’t try to stretch it to fit your mattress. You might tear it. You can either let it lie flat as the instructions recommend or, if you’re as impatient as I am, just put it on your mattress and let it flatten out under you. I loved this topper so much I bought one for my daughter to use on her terrible college dorm mattress.” —A B
17. A 2-inch egg crate topper in case you don’t wanna mess with a good thing.
Made of ventilated memory foam.
Promising review: “I never review anything on Amazon, but I had been truly suffering from Lumbar spondylosis. Facet DJD. Very slight retrolisthesis L2 upon L3 and L4 upon L5 and a likely small midline posterior annular tear at L4–L5. AKA BACK PAIN. For everything I did for my back (MRI, x-ray, saw a surgeon, a back doctor, got a new chair, took pills, did physical therapy, bought a ton of other pillows and chairs) the thing that has helped the most is this. To think I was going to buy a new mattress. This is the best.” —Anonymous
18. A 1-inch reversible topper in a dozen sizes so you can find a cushion that’ll work for the long haul.
Made of hypoallergenic down-alternative fill.
Promising review: “Have you ever been so happy with a purchase that you burst out in song? Whoop there it is! Whoop, whoop there it is! That is exactly how I felt after purchasing this topper! Earlier this year I purchased a memory foam mattress on Amazon that I love! But I wanted something to help protect it from Heidi my German Shepard who has a tendency to wallow in my bed while I am away at work, and pop the sheets off, and commence to diving under them like a frogman! Well, I saw in the descriptions how it has elastic anchor straps, and believe me they are Heidi-proof! Not only does this fit easily and snugly over my 11-inch mattress, it doesn’t pop off once Heidi starts her sheet scuba preparations, I really need to get this dog a snorkel! The topper it is so soft and luxurious! It feels 3x what it costs. I was in shock at how easy it is to put on, and how much of a difference it makes. Also, it easily fits in a standard washing machine and dryer. I have washed mine 3 or 4 times since I purchased it, and have had no issues, the filler has stayed in place and it bounces right back. I highly recommend the topper! Now if I could only get the dogs out of the bed!” —Rachel in Florida[the_ad id=”676″]
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.